Mykolo Romerio universitetas / Mykolas Romeris University
Reflections on the thesis that (natural) social rights preceded the creation of the social (welfare) state: Afterword to the Foreword by Nehal BhutaItem type:Publication, research article[2026][S1][S002,H001][10]International Journal Of Constitutional Law., 2026, p. 1-10This Afterword offers a philosophical engagement with Nehal Bhuta’s Foreword “Social Rights and the Origins of the Social Constitution” from the standpoint of Aristotelian–MacIntyrean virtue ethics, supplemented by Marx’s critique of capitalism. While endorsing Bhuta’s historical thesis—that natural social rights and their discourse preceded and helped constitute the modern welfare state—this Afterword argues that the language of rights is ethically and ontologically secondary. Rights emerge not as first principles of justice but as derivative claims arising from the breakdown of consent within social relations. The Afterword develops an alternative framework grounded in “activity,” “practice,” and “excellence” (aretē) as the foundational modes of human existence and cooperation. It then articulates two ethical-political principles: “consent,” rooted in the equal dignity of persons and constitutive of social justice, and “grace,” understood as the gratuitous gift and telos of a communist life, realizable only through excellence and shared flourishing. On this view, rights function as juridical responses to ruptured consent within capitalist societies that commodify human activity and privatize the commons. While Bhuta’s genealogy persuasively demonstrates the emancipatory role of natural social rights in resisting capitalist exclusion, such rights remain dependent on positive law and political power for their validity. This Afterword concludes that socialist justice—founded on merit and solidarity—prefigures a communist order of grace, in which the language of rights itself may ultimately wither away, replaced by relations grounded in consent, excellence, and the free gift.
3 Andrius Bielskis: On Revolution and New Forms of Anti-Capitalist Communal LivingItem type:Publication, research article[2025][S7][S002,H001][5]Lūžis : kultūros ir politikos žurnalas., 2025, p. 1-5The paper argues against Marxism-Leninist understanding of communism and socialism and argues that neither Soviet State socialism nor Western social demoracy eliminated workers’ alienation or the “slavery” of wage labour. It further argues as to what communism beyond Soviet-totalitarian nonsense might mean.
13 Enaction of mestizo identity in Pedro Páramo: transgression as care for the embodied soulItem type:Publication, research article[2025][S1][H001][18]; Carrillo, Juan CarlosFilosofia Unisinos., 2025, p. 1-18Juan Rulfo’s Pedro Páramo (1994 [1955]) is one of the milestones of Mexican literature and it holds an important place in the global canon of the twentieth century. Despite the wide spectrum of interpretative possibilities it offers, there are almost no studies of this important novel from the perspective of embodied cognition. This article draws on the vocabulary of contemporary philosophy to address this critical gap, deconstructing the full range of traditional binary oppositions articulated by Rulfo, which includes: body and mind, cognitive and moral, imaginative and perceptual, mystical and lived, freedom and responsibility, individual and social. However, to establish the relevancy of our chosen conceptual apparatus, we return to Aristotle to offer a novel interpretation which also allows us to situate and correlate both the universal (human) and particular (mestizo) projects laid out by the author of Páramo. We demonstrate both the usefulness of Aristotle’s universal descriptions of the human being and the shortcomings of their rationalism and optimism in the context of the postcolonial world. To modify and extend this adaptation we reflect further on the specific ‘movements’ of the mestizo soul, which privilege embodied moments of cognition and transgression as the proper care for the soul, a soul that embraces both individual and socio-cultural aspects. This finally allows us to address the question of how the post-logocentric enaction and mediation of mestizo identity is possible.
20 AristotelianismItem type:Publication, book part[2024][Y1][H001][10]Research Handbook on the History of Political Thought., 2024, p. 89-98The idea that Aristotelianism constitutes a distinct strand in the history of political thought has followed argument in the history of ethics, especially since Alasdair MacIntyre opposed an Aristotelian “tradition of the virtues” to “the Enlightenment project” in moral philosophy epitomized by Kant. MacIntyre’s historicization of Aristotelian ethics and politics is itself opposed by the rival Thomistic Aristotelianism of Terence Irwin, whose melding of Aristotelianism with modern theories, to which he offers it as a theoretical corrective, follows an Oxonian tradition in the history of political thought.
8 Theorising meaningful non-alienated labourItem type:Publication, research article[2024][S1b][H001][17]Critique: journal of socialist theory., 2024, p. 41-57.This paper aims to evaluate Marx’s conception of alienated labour from the point of view of Alasdair MacIntyre’s conception of practice. I will argue that Marx’s conception of alienation in The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 (and elsewhere) is too abstract, and therefore needs to be revised to reflect the reality of the 21st century. It presupposes that, in capitalism, all salaried and waged labour is alienated (a claim recently reiterated by Amy Wendling in her otherwise outstanding Karl Marx on Technology and Alienation). Clearly, this is not the case. The key characteristics of alienation as spelled out by Marx may not be present in a great variety of contemporary jobs dominated by services, especially if they are (or can be seen as) MacIntyrean practices (for example, practicing medicine in a public hospital or working as an engineer in a private company). Drawing on some of the most notable literature on the forms of alienation and reification, I will aim to theorise the conception of meaningful non-alienated labour. Given that practices, as meaningful non-alienated activities, are small islands of human excellence and resistance against the economic pressures of institutional profit maximisation and the self-valorisation of capital, I will conclude the paper by considering the political importance of this conception of labour for anti-capitalist struggles in the 21st century.
29Scopus© Citations 2 Judging automation: Towards a normative critical theoryItem type:Publication, research article[2023][S1][H001][18]Capital & class, 2023, vol. 00, no. 00, p. 1-18This article discusses automation from the point of view of the intersection between Aristotle and Marx. First, it was Aristotle’s notion of automatous – self-moving tools – that gave rise to the contemporary concept of automation. Marx’s historical materialism is important as it puts the ongoing process of automation into a historical perspective. The development of self-moving machines should free us from the slavery of hard work, yet the legal and political superstructure of capitalism means that the growth of automation produces new forms of precarious wage-slavery. Alasdair MacIntyre’s Aristotelian notion of practice is discussed vis-à-vis the Marxian notion of alienated labour. Given the conceptual structure – alienated labour (which prevents us from flourishing) versus non-alienated labour (as essential for human flourishing) – the article poses the question of whether we can apply this in our attempt to assess the ongoing process of automation.
45Scopus© Citations 3 - conference paper[2022][T2][S002,H001][19]Politics from the Margins: 72nd Political Studies Association Annual International Conference. The 2022 PSA Annual Conference, University of York, 13 April : Paper the PSA Marxism Specialist Group. [London] : Political Studies Association, 2022., p. 1-19
Aristotle’s brilliant thesis on automation is instructive: if our instruments moved on their own accord and each of them did its own work, “at the word of command or by intelligent anticipation”, master builders would need neither slaves nor servants. Today, contrary to Aristotle, we live in the era of automation, yet wage-slavery does exist. It has been argued that neoliberal wage-compression contributed to a record low levels of private investment. Even if we cannot draw a negative correlation between the investment in the development of automatization and the levels of exploitation, the increases in the exploitation of labour have an adverse effect on the level of investment in automation. It is therefore important to return to Marx’s theory of exploitation. According to Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Marx’s conceptualisation of exploitation in terms of the appropriation of surplus labour time is no longer relevant today given the post-modern transition from material to immaterial labour and the blurred distinction between leisure-time and worktime. Even if there is some truth in their claims, I will argue against them and in favour of Marx’s theory of exploitation. Following Capital Vol. I, the concept of Exploitation Calculus (EC) will be spelled out in the paper. Given that the source of surplus value and of exploitation lies in the appropriation of surplus labour time (SLT) at the expense of necessary labour time (NLT), EC will be defined as the ratio between SLT and NLT (i.e., EC=SLT/NLT). Marx assumes that EC is 1 in Capital Vol. I. I will then spell out the rational as to how to calculate EC in each capitalist company when the following three variables are known: number of workers, workers’ average salary, and the annual revenue of a company. Finally, several companies’ ECs will be revealed by way of illustration.
25 - conference paper[2021][T2][S002][9]ISME 2021 : Practical Rationality and Human Difference : The 14th Annual Conference of the International Society for MacIntyrean Enquiry. Bergamo : International Society of MacIntyrean Enquiry, 2021., p. 1-9
There is a lively debate among Aristotle’s scholars as to which political constitution is the best. In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle claims that it is monarchy (VIII.10.1160a35-36). The same claim is repeated, although less emphatically, in the Politics (III.18.1288a15-18). Yet in the Politics book VII, Aristotle argues that the best polis looks very much politeia like, that is to say, where citizens rule and are ruled in turns. Given Aristotle’s philosophical definition of the polis (it “is an association of equals (τῶν ὁμοίων) for the sake of best life possible” while “the best (τὸ ἄριστον) is happiness (εὐδαιμονία) and that consists in (moral) excellence (ἀρετῆς) and its perfect (τέλειος) actualisation (ἐνέργεια) and its employment (χρῆσις)” (Pol.VII.1328a35-3)) and his argument on the relationship between the good man and the good citizen, I will argue that the best constitution is and ought to be politeia. Yet to argue so is not enough if we want to rescue Aristotle from his xenophobic, aristocratic, and sexist bias. We need further to misread Aristotle to argue that the sharp separation between oikos and polis as well as the verticality of the former are both philosophically arbitrary and contradict his philosophical-methodological conception of teleology.
14 Virtue Ethics and Contemporary Aristotelianism: Modernity, Conflict and PoliticsItem type:Publication, book[2020][K5][S002,H001][244]; ;Leontsini, EleniKnight, KelvinLondon: Bloomsbury, 2020This compelling and distinctive volume advances Aristotelianism by bringing its traditional virtue ethics to bear upon characteristically modern issues, such as the politics of economic power and egalitarian dispute. This volume bridges the gap between Aristotle's philosophy and the multitude of contemporary Aristotelian theories that have been formulated in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. Part I draws on Aristotle's texts and Thomas Aquinas' Aristotelianism to examine the Aristotelian tradition of virtues, with a chapter by Alasdair MacIntyre contextualising the different readings of Aristotle's philosophy. Part II offers a critical engagement with MacIntyrean Aristotelianism, while Part III demonstrates the ongoing influence of Aristotelianism in contemporary theoretical debates on governance and politics. Extensive in its historical scope, this is a valuable collection relating the tradition of virtue to modernity, which will be of interest to all working in virtue ethics and contemporary Aristotelian politics.
14 Human flourishing and labour: Aristotle, MacIntyre and MarxItem type:Publication, book part[2020][Y1][H001][14]Virtue Ethics and Contemporary Aristotelianism : Modernity, Conflict and Politics / Edited by Andrius Bielskis, Eleni Leontsini, and Kelvin Knight. London : Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN 9781350122178., p. 208-221Aristotle’s exclusion of workers from the ideal polis is well known to any student of Aristotle’s ethical and political works. In order for Aristotelian considerations on human flourishing, as well as for any other philosophical approach as to what is conducive for human well-being, to have relevance for contemporary societies, the question of labour must be made central: most of us, after all, need to work to earn a living. Thus, Aristotle’s views on the status of workers are not negligible when considering his ethical theory. In this chapter, my aim is not to reject or accept Aristotle’s arguments, but to highlight the tension between human flourishing and labour, as it appears in Aristotle’s works, and then to comment on two different attempts to deal with this tension: Alasdair MacIntyre’s and Karl Marx’s. I start with Aristotle’s arguments of why workers cannot be citizens of the best polis and lead a flourishing life. I then turn to MacIntyre’s attempt to make Aristotle’s ethics more egalitarian and to reconnect virtue with work. Finally, I introduce Marx’s considerations about freedom and labour to show that Marx retains and radicalizes some of Aristotle’s arguments about human flourishing
16