Šavelskis, Mykolas
Ensuring the principle of the best interests of the child: the case of transposition and implementation of the Directives 2013/32/EU and 2013/33/EU in LithuaniaItem type:Publication, research article[2016][S7][S001][33]Migration, borders control and solidarity: Schengen at stake? : IED Research Papers. Brussels : Institut of European Democrats, 2016., p. 1-33This article analyses and evaluates the transposition of the latest Common European Asylum System Directives 2013/32/EU on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection and 2013/33/EU laying down standards for the reception of applicants for international protection in Lithuania, concentrating on the ensuring one of the most prominent contemporary human rights principle, also enshrined in these two directives - the best interests of the child. For this purpose, Lithuanian legislation is analyzed and evaluated, indicating good and bad transposition and implementation practices; also practical recommendations how to improve transposition and implementation and thus strengthen CEAS and make it more effective are formulated.
9 - research article[2013][S1b][S001][23]
; ; Baltic journal of law & politics. Kaunas ; Warsaw : Vytautas Magnus University ; Versita, 2013, vol. 6, Nr. 1., p. 140-162The traditional theories of judicial decision-making have their differences set around the importance of logical, rule-bound, and step-by-step reasoning. For legal formalists, judicial decision-making is predominantly a logical and rule-bound process, and ideally it is a product of syllogistic reasoning. For original legal realists and their contemporary counterparts, judicial decision-making is rarely a logical, step-by-step, and rule-bound process; more often than not, it is better epitomized by intuitive decisions. For a long time this question remained open. The purpose of this article is accordingly twofold. First, by relying on empirical research on decision-making, we argue that logical and rule-bound judicial decision-making, although possible in theory, is highly unlikely in practice. Second, by relying on indirect empirical evidence, we show that judges are very likely to possess unexceptional decision-making skills even when it comes to aspects of decision-making that have not been specifically tested on judges.
32 29Scopus© Citations 4