Mykolo Romerio universiteto mokslo valdymo sistema (CRIS)





Mokslininko profilio nuoroda: https://cris.mruni.eu/cris/handle/007/20140
Rodoma1 - 2 iš 2
  • research article[2021][S1b][S001][15]; ;
    Tilburg Law Review. London : Ubiquity Press, 2021, vol. 26, iss. 21., p. 1-15

    The European Convention on Human Rights, the regional international treaty adopted in 1950, requires that any restriction, limitation, or interference with the rights and freedoms guaranteed in the Convention should be ‘prescribed by law’, ‘in accordance with the law’ or ‘provided by law’. In the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights, the assessment of ‘legality’ requires that the impugned measure have a legal basis in national law, and refers to the quality of law. At the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic, numerous states worldwide rolled out a patchwork of different provisions limiting (restricting) the implementation of human rights and fundamental freedoms. Understandably, the immediacy of the emergency required a quick and efficient reaction from states; therefore, some situationally appropriate, however aggressive, restrictions on the exercise of human rights were imposed without a proper legal basis in national law. The article deals with the concept of the legality of limitations (restrictions) on the implementation of human rights and fundamental freedoms in a public health emergency, and in particular, the question of whether Article 15 of the Convention includes the possibility to deviate from the “classical” legality standard. The ‘derogation clause’ enshrined in Article 15 and the ‘restrictive clause’ established in, e.g., the second paragraphs of Articles 8–11, have an essential value in assessing the ‘legality’ of interference in the exercise of the Convention rights and freedoms during the COVID-19 pandemic, especially in cases where States Parties to the Convention had not used the possibility to derogate from the Convention obligations under Article 15. Relying on the case-law of the ECtHR in respect of the legality of interference in the exercise of human rights, the authors argue that legality in a state of emergency should follow the same logic as in the absence of such a state. This is reflected in the constitutional case-law, although the national dimension of the legality requirement varies depending on different constitutional arrangements in the countries.

      77  24Scopus© citavimai 4
  • Item type:Publikacija,
    Konstitucinis Non bis in idem principas baudžiamojoje justicijoje: šiuolaikinė samprata ir aktualūs taikymo klausimai
    [The constitutional non bis in idem principle in criminal justice: the contemporary concept and current issues of application]
    research article[2021][S5][S001][44];
    Konstitucija ir teisinė sistema. Liber Amicorum Vytautui Sinkevičiui : [recenzuotų mokslo straipsnių rinkinys]. Vilnius : Mykolo Romerio universitetas, 2021. ISBN 9786094880162., p. 599-642

    Straipsnyje nagrinėjamas visuotinai pripažintas teisės principas, draudžiantis dvigubą baudimą už tą patį nusikaltimą (non bis in idem). Tyrime išskiriami esminiai šio principo elementai, išvystyti Europos Žmogaus Teisių Teismo ir Europos Sąjungos Teisingumo Teismo sprendimuose, Lietuvos Respublikos Konstitucinio Teismo nutarimuose, Lietuvos Aukščiausiojo Teismo nutartyse. Straipsnyje pateikiama non bis in idem principo loginė struktūra ir pabrėžiama, kad jos turinį atskleidžia atsakymai į tris esminius klausimus: 1) ką reiškia už nusikaltimą; 2) ką reiškia už tą patį (idem); 3) ką reiškia antrą kartą (bis) bausti ar persekioti. Išsamūs atsakymai į šiuos klausimus ir sudaro straipsnio turinį. Taip pat aptariamos klaidos, lemiančios non bis in idem pažeidimų nustatymą konkrečioje byloje, nurodomi šių pažeidimų galimi ištaisymo variantai, kuriuos gali pasirinkti teismas, atsižvelgdamas į baudžiamosios bylos specifiką.

      175  99