Serhieieva, Alina
Judicial independence De Jure and De acto: lessons for Ukraine from the case law of the ECtHRItem type:Publikacija, research article[2024][S1b][S001][11] ;Tsuvina, Tetiana A.International comparative jurisprudence., 2024, p. 50-60The principle of judicial independence is a fundamental tenet of the rule of law and fair trial standards. The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) identifies four criteria for evaluating judicial independence: (a) the manner of a judge’s appointment; (b) the duration of such an appointment; (c) safeguards against external influence; and (d) the appearance of independence. The ECtHR also distinguishes several dimensions of judicial independence, including independence vis-à-vis the executive, parliament, other courts, and parties, as well as independence from judicial councils. Nevertheless, despite the existence of shared European principles on judicial independence, certain countries, particularly those undergoing transitions, encounter challenges such as political interference, corruption, and insufficient safeguards against dismissal. This results in a discernible disjunction between de jure and de facto judicial independence. This article poses the following research questions: What are the main approaches and common challenges for judicial independence in European countries based on the latest case law of the ECtHR? What lessons can be learned by Ukraine, as an EU candidate, from this case law in order to mitigate the gap between de jure and de facto judicial independence?
17 11Scopus© citavimai 2 When a State Is a Party to a Dispute - (Court-)Administrative Mediation in Poland and in Ukraine (A Comparative Perspective)Item type:Publikacija, research article[2023][S1][S001][20] ;Kalisz, AnnaReview of European and Comparative Law, 2023, vol. 53, no. 2, p. 129-148Ukraine's status as a candidate country for the European Union membership reinforces the need for comparative analysis between Ukrainian regulations and the laws of other EU Member States, as well as European regulations. One of the fields of comparative law is the development of mediation as a legal institution, also in cases when the state is involved - for disputes covered by administrative law. This has already been a subject of interest and promotion of both the EU and the Council of Europe, as European standards of democracy provide for the state's cooperation with citizens/individuals. The aim of this article is - firstly - to compare the current development of mediation in administrative and court -administrative cases in Poland and in Ukraine, the similarities in successes and challenges, and - secondly - to determine to what extent both countries follow the latest CEPEJ guidelines. Although the state of research and literature on this subject is advanced in Poland and slightly less satisfactory in Ukraine, a comparative overview of this type of mediation regulations can be considered a novum. As for methodology, the paper is dominated by the logical-linguistic method, although some conclusions were drawn on the basis of both statistics and participant observation, i.e. the authors' own mediation practice. So far - although both legal systems are quite compatible with the CEPEJ guidelines examined and provide for inter-branch solutions - in both countries in question, the development of administrative and court-administrative mediation is not a "success story." A contrario: it can be classified as developing in the least resilient manner. To some extent, Poland and Ukraine show similarities and correlations in terms of successes and challenges, as well as social and mental barriers to mediation development.
26Scopus© citavimai 4 Access to justice in civil cases: Filling the gap in the sustainable development agendaItem type:Publikacija, book part[2023][Y1][S001][13]; Tsuvina, TetianaLaw and sustainability: Perspectives for Lithuania and Beyond / editors: Alessio Bartolacelli, Dovilė Sagatienė ; Mykolas Romeris University, 2023, p. 241-25325 27Scopus© citavimai 1 Right to be heard as a part of due process of law in arbitration proceedings: current challenges and lessons for UkraineItem type:Publikacija, research article[2023][S1b][S001][19] ;Serhii, KravtsovRevista Brasileira de Alternative Dispute Resolution., 2023, p. 221-239.International commercial arbitration as a type of alternative dispute resolution is gaining popularity quite rapidly and its use is not the result of a lack of trust in national courts, but a desire to resolve a dispute as soon as possible with the least amount of time and the ability to manage the process independently. This can be considered one of the most important reasons for choosing arbitration, as the events of the last 5 years in the world (such as the Pandemic, Climate change) have demonstrated to everyone the importance of prompt communication and, as a result, the importance of introducing various forms of arbitration proceedings. Such forms include direct (traditional) consideration of the case in the arbitration courtroom, online and hybrid forms. And in this aspect, a fairly reasonable question arises as to whether such forms of arbitration proceedings comply with the due process of law. The article will analyze the doctrinal approaches of both Ukrainian and foreign legal schools and examples of the law enforcement practice of national courts on this problematic issue. In addition, the article will analyze the Ukrainian legislation on the compliance of arbitration proceedings with due process of law and propose amendments to the current legislation. The article consists of 3 main parts which are logically interrelated and methodologically structured. The first part is devoted to the analysis of the main approaches to due process of law, which is revealed through the prism of comparative legal analysis of doctrinal concepts and analysis of law enforcement practice of national and arbitration courts. The second part reveals the essence of such a structural element of the due process of law in arbitration proceedings as the right to be heard, which plays a key role not only in the course of international commercial arbitration proceedings, but also in the procedure for recognition and enforcement of international commercial arbitration awards by national courts. The last section reveals the peculiarities of due process in virtual arbitration as a specific mechanism of alternative dispute resolution. Using a comparative legal analysis of arbitration practice and the current rules of the leading arbitration institutions, the author concludes that the introduction of online mechanisms in arbitration proceedings is effective.
15 13Scopus© citavimai 1 The Development of Mediation in Poland and Ukraine: A Comparison and Prospects for Experience ExchangeItem type:Publikacija, research article[2023][S1b][S001][21] ;Kalisz, AnnaStudia Iuridica Lublinensia, 2023, vol. 32, no. 3, p. 89-109Ukraine has become a candidate country for the European Union membership, which brings challenges, including those of a legal nature. One of such challenges is the regulation of the institution of mediation, which is a subject of interest to European institutions (both within the Council of Europe and the European Union) that actively promote methods of alternative dispute resolution (ADR methods). The aim of the article is to compare the current development of mediation in Poland and Ukraine, as well as to determine to what extent there are similarities in successes and challenges and to what extent the Polish experience could be helpful for the development of mediation in Ukraine. The essence of the problem is whether Ukraine shall follow Polish solutions in this area.
12 18Scopus© citavimai 2 CEPEJ Gudelines for Mediation Resolving Administrative Disputes – A Comparison between Council of Europe States and Ukrainian PerspectivesItem type:Publikacija, [Wytyczne CEPEJ dotyczące rozwiązywania sporów administracyjnych za pomocą mediacji – porównanie perspektywy państw rady Europy i Ukrainy.]research article[2023][S1b][S001][10]Acta Universitatis Lodziensis. Folia Iuridica., 2023, p. 185-194.The status of Ukraine as a candidate country for the European Union membership reinforces the need for comparative analysis between Ukrainian regulations and law of other EU Member States as well as European regulations. One ofthe fields of comparative law is a development of mediation for disputes covered by administrative law. It has already been a subject of interest and promotion to both - The EU and the Council of Europe, since European standards of democracy provide for state cooperate with citizens individuals. The aim of this article is, to examine the main provisions, recommendations and best practices of the CoE member states, and to analyse the current practice and existing gaps in Ukraine in order to develop a proposal for effective implementation in the light of the most recent CEPEJ Guidelines promoting mediation to resolve administrative disputes. A comparative overview of this type of mediation regulations may be considered as novum. As for methodology, the paper is dominated by the logical-linguistic and comparative method. So far-though Ukrainian legal system is quite compatibile with the examined CEPEJ gudelines and provide for inter-branch solutions - the development of administrative and court-administrative mediation is quite resilient and there is still much to be done not solely with legal regulations, but also..mediation culture'' in such field.
18 17Scopus© citavimai 1