Ažubalytė, Rima
Towards Coherence in Criminal Justice: Challenges, Discussions and/or SolutionsItem type:Publication, book[2024][K5][S001][310]; ; Berlin : Peter Lang, 2024This book explores the pursuit of coherence in criminal justice, addressing how criminal laws and practices can become more rational and aligned with human rights principles. It examines key criminal justice principles like legality, proportionality, and presumption of innocence, aiming to adapt them to modern societal and technological challenges. The work highlights the growing influence of international conventions and European courts on national legal systems, emphasizing the need for thoughtful implementation of transnational precedents. While focused on Lithuanian criminal justice, topics like human trafficking, drug possession, and electronic evidence are relevant across Europe, offering insights for legal researchers globally.
44 38 - book part[2024][Y1][S001][9]
; ; Towards Coherence in Criminal Justice: Challenges, Discussions and/or Solutions / Jolanta Zajančkauskienė, Rima Ažubalytė, Oleg Fedosiuk (eds.), 2024, p. 287-295Coherence in law, including criminal justice, is a minimum condition for rationality. Coherence is not superior to other values; however, it is believed that coherence should be pursued in every area of criminal justice to avoid arbitrariness and injustice. At the very least, efforts should be made to correct the most glaring inconsistencies, errors, or discrepancies, although it is sometimes difficult, if not impossible, to agree on what full coherence really is. The authors of this edited volume therefore draw conclusions, make suggestions, and raise questions for discussion after researching multiple varying areas of criminal justice in the context of coherent regulation and its application.
7 16 - book part[2024][Y1][S001][41]Towards Coherence in Criminal Justice: Challenges, Discussions and/or Solutions / Jolanta Zajančkauskienė, Rima Ažubalytė, Oleg Fedosiuk (eds.)., 2024, p. 203-243
One of the most serious concerns among European countries and the EU is the protection of society against crime, especially transnational crime. For this reason, authorities, researchers, and practitioners analyze solutions that should enable them to deprive the perpetrators of crime of their profits in an effective way. Thus, the third chapter (“Evidence in Non-Conviction-Based Confiscation Proceedings”) analyzes one of the most pertinent issues in confiscation proceedings – the standard of evidence in non-conviction-based confiscation proceedings and its compatibility with human rights, in particular the presumption of innocence. This chapter analyzes the coherence of international rules in nonconviction- based confiscation with national, including constitutional, standards of limitations of the right to property. International and EU approaches to asset confiscation and the jurisprudence of supranational courts are characterized by the continuous expansion of the concept and scope of non-conviction-based confiscation. On the other hand, in order to achieve effective cooperation, states must also strive for coherence, not only in regulating the grounds for confiscation, but also in ensuring the equal protection of individual rights. This includes setting an appropriate standard of proof in non-conviction-based confiscation proceedings. An analysis of the jurisprudence of constitutional courts on extended confiscation suggests that national jurisprudence also seeks coherence with that of the ECtHR and the CJEU by, inter alia, setting a different standard of proof. Nevertheless, the tension between the rights of the individual and the state’s objective of recovering the proceeds of crime in non-convictionbased confiscation remains.
18 16 The Right of the Accused to Be Informed as a Condition for the Legality of Criminal Proceedings in absentia in the Context of War Crimes and Crimes Against HumanityItem type:Publication, book part[2024][Y1][S001][23]The Impact of War and Extraordinary Situations on Law in the Context of Agression against Ukraine / Lyra Jakulevičienė, Patrick R. Hugg, Dmytro Luchenko (eds.)., 2024, p. 173-19512 25 Specialiųjų žinių vertinimas įrodinėjimo proceseItem type:Publication, [The evaluation of special knowledge in the process of proof: general procedural and substantive requirements of criminal case-law.]Šiame straipsnyje, daugiausia remiantis EŽTT ir kasacinės instancijos teismo jurisprudencija, diskutuojama specialiųjų žinių tyrimo ir vertinimo teismuose klausimais. Prieš pradedant nagrinėti procedūrinius ir materialiuosius reikalavimus ekspertinių tyrimų rezultatų vertinimui teisme, straipsnyje pagrindžiama pozicija, kad įrodinėjimo kontekste, kuris nagrinėjamas šiame straipsnyje, teisinės žinios nelaikomos specialiosiomis. Toliau straipsnyje analizuojami procedūriniai reikalavimai ekspertinių tyrimų vertinimui teisme, kuriems iki šiol Lietuvos doktrinoje iš esmės neskirta dėmesio. Paskutinė straipsnio dalis skiriama bendriesiems specialiųjų žinių (kaip įrodymo) turinio vertinimo reikalavimams.
7 16 Accessible and sustainable criminal justice: The right of an incapacited accused person to be present at a court hearingItem type:Publication, book part[2023][Y1][S001][31]; Law and sustainability: Perspectives for Lithuania and Beyond / editors: Alessio Bartolacelli, Dovilė Sagatienė ; Mykolas Romeris University., 2023, p. 309-339.37 23Scopus© Citations 1 - research article[2022][S1b][S001][15]
; Titko, IvanInternational comparative jurisprudence. Vilnius : Mykolo Romerio universitetas, 2022, vol. 8, iss. 2., p. 178-192One of the most important procedural rights of the individual, without which it would be impossible to defend all other potentially violated individual rights, including those potentially violated during a pandemic, is the constitutional right to a court enshrined in Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 47 of the European Union Charter of Fundamental Rights. The health crisis has plagued many judicial systems in the absence of specific regulations that would provide a clear answer to the question of how to pursue justice in court, and especially to what extent it is possible to use the form of remote – working. This article, analyzes the question of whether the entire criminal trial can take place remotely and, if yes, whether remote criminal trial meets the requirements of due process: both substantive and procedural. The article analyzes the basic requirements of a fair trial, such as the right to be present and be heard, the right to defense; the right to trial within a reasonable time; the right to a public trial. However, even after all issues have been resolved, a more in-depth discussion on the compliance of entire remote criminal proceedings with the principles of a fair trial is needed. The practical analysis of the scientific problem is based mainly on the legal regulation of ECHR and relevant case law of the ECtHR, as well as the experience of two well-known to the authors jurisdictions - Lithuania and Ukraine - in the context of the pandemic.
24 50Scopus© Citations 3 Legal Principles vs. Statutory Ambiguity in Criminal Justice: Lithuanian Court ExperienceItem type:Publication, research article[2021][S1][S001][23]; Criminal Law Forum. Dordrecht : Springer, 2021, vol 32, iss. 3, 8383., p. 435-457In any state where the rule of law is applied, criminal justice serves to guarantee the efficiency and legitimacy of liability and all legally sanctioned coercive measures. Its purpose is also to eliminate, insofar as is possible, any arbitrariness and dishonesty arising in the course of criminal prosecution. Thus, the rules underpinning criminal law and procedure, formulated precisely, harmonized, and based on the principles of law, are the theoretical basis for the attainment of those objectives. In reality, however, the activity of the legislator in drafting new laws and slowed progress in eliminating outdated and unjustified norms creates a situation where the wording of legal codes gradually loses their systematic and consistent character. In recent years, the phenomenon of over-criminalization and statutory ambiguity has attracted an enormous amount of research interest in criminal science. A number of legal concepts and principles are used to discipline the legislature, and thereby allow the courts to apply the law prudently and with great caution, within the limits of their constitutional powers, and in accordance with local legal traditions. This paper presents those legal principles followed by the Lithuanian courts to ensure the proportionate application of substantive criminal law and special investigative techniques, inter alia secret surveillance, thereby offsetting the impact of poorly drafted laws on human rights.
16Scopus© Citations 3 Legality of Human Rights Restrictions During the COVID-19 Pandemic Under the European Convention on Human RightsItem type:Publication, research article[2021][S1b][S001][15]; ; Tilburg Law Review. London : Ubiquity Press, 2021, vol. 26, iss. 21., p. 1-15The European Convention on Human Rights, the regional international treaty adopted in 1950, requires that any restriction, limitation, or interference with the rights and freedoms guaranteed in the Convention should be ‘prescribed by law’, ‘in accordance with the law’ or ‘provided by law’. In the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights, the assessment of ‘legality’ requires that the impugned measure have a legal basis in national law, and refers to the quality of law. At the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic, numerous states worldwide rolled out a patchwork of different provisions limiting (restricting) the implementation of human rights and fundamental freedoms. Understandably, the immediacy of the emergency required a quick and efficient reaction from states; therefore, some situationally appropriate, however aggressive, restrictions on the exercise of human rights were imposed without a proper legal basis in national law. The article deals with the concept of the legality of limitations (restrictions) on the implementation of human rights and fundamental freedoms in a public health emergency, and in particular, the question of whether Article 15 of the Convention includes the possibility to deviate from the “classical” legality standard. The ‘derogation clause’ enshrined in Article 15 and the ‘restrictive clause’ established in, e.g., the second paragraphs of Articles 8–11, have an essential value in assessing the ‘legality’ of interference in the exercise of the Convention rights and freedoms during the COVID-19 pandemic, especially in cases where States Parties to the Convention had not used the possibility to derogate from the Convention obligations under Article 15. Relying on the case-law of the ECtHR in respect of the legality of interference in the exercise of human rights, the authors argue that legality in a state of emergency should follow the same logic as in the absence of such a state. This is reflected in the constitutional case-law, although the national dimension of the legality requirement varies depending on different constitutional arrangements in the countries.
77 24Scopus© Citations 4 Konstitucinis Non bis in idem principas baudžiamojoje justicijoje: šiuolaikinė samprata ir aktualūs taikymo klausimaiItem type:Publication, [The constitutional non bis in idem principle in criminal justice: the contemporary concept and current issues of application]research article[2021][S5][S001][44]; Konstitucija ir teisinė sistema. Liber Amicorum Vytautui Sinkevičiui : [recenzuotų mokslo straipsnių rinkinys]. Vilnius : Mykolo Romerio universitetas, 2021. ISBN 9786094880162., p. 599-642Straipsnyje nagrinėjamas visuotinai pripažintas teisės principas, draudžiantis dvigubą baudimą už tą patį nusikaltimą (non bis in idem). Tyrime išskiriami esminiai šio principo elementai, išvystyti Europos Žmogaus Teisių Teismo ir Europos Sąjungos Teisingumo Teismo sprendimuose, Lietuvos Respublikos Konstitucinio Teismo nutarimuose, Lietuvos Aukščiausiojo Teismo nutartyse. Straipsnyje pateikiama non bis in idem principo loginė struktūra ir pabrėžiama, kad jos turinį atskleidžia atsakymai į tris esminius klausimus: 1) ką reiškia už nusikaltimą; 2) ką reiškia už tą patį (idem); 3) ką reiškia antrą kartą (bis) bausti ar persekioti. Išsamūs atsakymai į šiuos klausimus ir sudaro straipsnio turinį. Taip pat aptariamos klaidos, lemiančios non bis in idem pažeidimų nustatymą konkrečioje byloje, nurodomi šių pažeidimų galimi ištaisymo variantai, kuriuos gali pasirinkti teismas, atsižvelgdamas į baudžiamosios bylos specifiką.
175 99