The Privilege of Advocate-Client Communication Lex Lata and De Lege Ferenda: an Analysis of the Case of Lithuanian Detention Centers
| Data | Puslapis nuo | Puslapis iki |
|---|---|---|
2026 | 242 | 254 |
Article examines a topical and practically problematic issue: the inviolability of communications between an advocate and his client in criminal proceedings. Specifically, the analysis shows that although, in the theory of criminal procedure law, the right to defence cannot be restricted in any way, and the inviolability of communication with an advocate must be strictly respected, certain normative acts of the Republic of Lithuania do not ensure these guarantees. Accordingly, inadequate legal regulation also poses challenges for practical application. The specific case under examination involves a situation where the communication of a suspect or defendant detained in Lithuanian police detention facilities with an advocate representing them is monitored using video and audio recording devices. The normative acts regulating this procedure provide that such recording is allegedly necessary to ensure public order and the safety of and advocate himself. However, such arguments should be viewed more as an attempt to justify the aforementioned regulation than to amend it so that it complies with the requirements of the right to a defence.