Miliuvienė, Jolita
Judicial Activism in Defence of the Constitution: The Role of the Constitutional Court in Safeguarding the Rule of Law and Democratic ResilienceItem type:Publication, research article[2026][P1c][S001][13]Rule of Law in Times of Change : Contributions to the World Law Congress 2025 in Santo Domingo, 2026, p. 325-337This paper seeks to explore where the boundaries of constitutional court activism ought to be drawn when courts adjudicate sensitive issues related to fundamental rights. The analysis focuses on a decision of the Lithuanian Constitutional Court, where it held that the legislature is under a constitutional duty to provide for the legal recognition and registration of same-sex partnerships, thereby affirming that the constitutional concept of family extends beyond heterosexual unions. This case study is examined not in isolation but within a broader comparative and theoretical discourse on constitutional adjudication, judicial activism, and the role of courts in safeguarding democracy. The argument advanced is that, in times of democratic contestation and human rights retrenchment, such interventions may be indispensable for the preservation of constitutionalism and the protection of individuals. In those cases, constitutional courts often function as catalysts of social change when they hand down decisions for which society is not yet fully prepared. Over time, societies tend to adapt to new concepts and requirements. Without a bold and active—though not activist—constitutional court, societies might ultimately reach the same recognition of rights on their own, but only after a much longer and more painful process.
German Legal Thought in Lithuanian Constitutionalism. The Impact of the Jurisprudence of the Federal Constitutional Court on Lithuanian Constitutional DevelopmentItem type:Publication, book part[2026][Y1][S001][18]Der Blick von außen – A View from Outside / edited by Matthias Jestaedt, Anna-Bettina Kaiser, Angelika Nußberger, Andreas Voßkuhle : Internationale Festgabe zum 75. Geburtstag des Bundesverfassungsgerichts : International Liber Amicorum of the 75th Anniversary of the Federal Constitutional Court., 2026, p. 487-504Following the fall of the Berlin Wall and the collapse of the Soviet Union, newly re-established democratic states moved swiftly to consolidate their regained independence. Lithuania was the first of the Baltic States to declare its withdrawal from the Soviet Union. Upon the restoration of independence, the country required a new constitution, as the last one in force prior to the Soviet occupation, the 1938 Constitution of Lithuania, was neither fully democratic nor aligned with the expectations of a modern state. Its validity was restored for a few minutes to mark the continuation of the state that existed before the occupation, only to be suspended right away. The newly adopted 1992 Constitution introduced, for the first time in Lithuanian legal history, the establishment of a constitutional review body – the Constitutional Court. By opting for the European model of constitutional review, as did Latvia (and unlike Estonia, where constitutional review is entrusted to the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court), Lithuania established a new separate institution with the mission entrusted to it to ensure the supremacy of the Constitution. review body overseeing other branches of government was not entirely novel. As early as the interwar period, the Lithuanian constitutional theorist Mykolas Römeris had analysed European practice and argued in favour of the necessity of such an institution.
3 Vertical and Horizontal Layers of the Lithuanian ConstitutionItem type:Publication, book part[2026][Y1][S001][19]; Multi-Textual Constitutions of the World / edited by Richard Albert, 2026, p. 113-131The concept of constitutional multi-textuality challenges the traditional perceptions of constitutions as single cohesive legal documents. Multi-textual constitutions consist of multiple documents with shared legal supremacy, thereby challenging conventional understandings of constitutional unity and rejecting the dichotomy between written and unwritten constitutions. The theoretical foundations for analysing multi-textual constitutions can be traced to broader inquiries into constitutional pluralism and modularity, which examine how constitutions incorporate diverse sources of legal authority shaped by historical contingencies, political compromises, and external influences. These interactions underscore the dynamic and multi-layered composition of constitutional authority, where historical texts coexist with modern amendments. [1]R Albert, ‘Multi-Textual Constitutions’ (2023) Virginia Law Review 1632, 1633. [2]DJ Galligan and M Versteeg, The Social and Political Foundations of Constitutions (Cambridge University Press, 2013) 36. The Lithuanian Constitution of 1992 exemplifies this phenomenon through a unique constitutional design that integrates multiple constituent acts, creating a layered and dynamic framework of constitutional governance. This multi-textual nature is not only reflected in the Constitution’s foundational design, where constituent acts adopted both prior to and following the its promulgation are endowed with supreme constitutional authority, but also in its ongoing evolution through judicial interpretation. Such a composite structure situates the Lithuanian Constitution at the intersection of codified integrity and fluid adaptability, raising questions about its coherence, hierarchy, and practical application. This chapter explores the theoretical and practical dimensions of the Lithuanian Constitution’s multi-textuality, revealing how it fulfils all three features common to the multi-textual constitutions: multiplicity, asynchrony, and shared supremacy. Also, the Lithuanian experience reflects the dynamic interplay between historical legacies and contemporary developments that shaped the emergence of the new Constitution adopted following Lithuania’s re-establishment of the independent state....
Pasauliui kintant, šalių konstitucijos išlieka pasaulio demokratijos stuburu: kaip ir kodėl?Item type:Publication, Konstitucija – tarsi valstybės stuburas: lakoniškame dokumente įtvirtintos pagrindinės vertybės išlieka gyvos ir aktualios, nepaisant besikeičiančių laikų. Kiekviena valstybė turi savo konstituciją – ne tik aukščiausios galios teisės aktą, bet ir visos teisinės sistemos pamatą. Nuo jos priklauso teisinės tvarkos darnumas, nuspėjamumas ir valstybės veikimo stabilumas. Mykolo Romerio universiteto (MRU) mokslininkė, konstitucinės ir lyginamosios konstitucinės teisės tyrėja, doc. dr. Jolita Miliuvienė pastebi, kad Konstitucija turi gebėti reaguoti į visuomenės pokyčius, tačiau tai daryti atsispirdama nuo laiko patikrintų vertybių. Pokalbio metu mokslininkė dalijosi įžvalgomis apie demokratijos būklę įvairiuose pasaulio regionuose, Konstitucijos raidos ir jos dvasios sampratą bei teisės gebėjimą prisitaikyti prie kintančio pasaulio aktualijų.
6 LithuaniaItem type:Publication, book part[2025][Y2][S001][5]The 2024 International Review of Constitutional Reform / edited by Luís Roberto Barroso, Richard Albert, 2025, p. 283-287Lithuania stands out among democratic states for its unusually high number of impeachment proceedings resulting in findings of gross violation of the Constitution and breach of the oath given to the state and the people. It was one of the first states in the world to impeach and remove from office the President of the Republic1 . The year 2024 was no exception: one parliamentarian was impeached for making antisemitic remarks, both during parliamentary proceedings and on social media platforms2 . This latest case highlighted some long-standing challenges and emerging questions concerning the effectiveness and integrity of the Constitutional impeachment procedure.
6 Konstitucinė justicijaItem type:Publication, book part[2025][Y4][S001][62]; ; Lyginamoji konstitucinė teisė : antras papildytas leidimas : vadovėlis, 2025, p. 219-28016 LithuaniaItem type:Publication, book part[2024][Y2][S001][5]The 2023 Global Review of Constitutional Law / edited by Richard Albert, David Landau, Pietro Faraguna, Giulia De Rossi Andrade., 2024, p. 245-2494 LithuaniaItem type:Publication, research article[2024][S5][S001][4]The International Review of Constitutional Reform 2023 / edited by Luís Roberto Barroso, Richard Albert., 2024, p. 225-22827 How to avoid constitutional court-packing in an era of democratic backsliding: Reflections on the appointment of constitutional judgesItem type:Publication, research article[2024][S1b][S001][22]Hungarian journal of legal studies. Acta Juridica Hungarica., 2024, p. 1-22Any struggles in the nomination and appointment of constitutional justices and failed renewal of the composition of the constitutional court might corrupt the perception of the independence of the guardian of constitutionality. The recent wave of impropriate renewals of constitutional courts throughout Europe leads to substantial concern. There are numerous more or less serious examples, including the well-known cases of Poland and Hungary, but alongside with them Latvia, Lithuania, the Slovak Republic, etc. In an era of democratic back-sliding more significant in some countries and less in others, it leads to wondering whether the influence of politics in power could be the critical factor distorting the composition of constitutional courts and whether this can be seen as a new virus infecting new democracies. After analyzing the recent failures to appoint constitutional justices, caused essentially by malfunction due to political actors participating in the process, the paper argues that in the selection, nomination, and appointment of constitutional justices, ensuring the depoliticization of this procedure is not the best choice, because the participation of democratically elected institutions in the formation of the constitutional courts enhances their legitimacy and credibility. The former, entrusted with the power to adopt erga omnes decisions, desperately need this legitimation. Different political cultures and contrasts in states' constitutional orders suggest that there is hardly one recipe that fits all. However, some universal and fundamental criteria stemming from the principle of the rule of law intended to ensure the independence of constitutional justice could bind the discretion of political actors participating in the nomination and appointment of constitutional judges and contribute to preventing constitutional crises.
21 Konstitucinio Teismo bendradarbiavimas su tarptautiniais teismaisItem type:Publication, research article[2023][S5][S001][5]; Trisdešimt konstitucinės justicijos metų: tempore et loco, 2023, p. 557-56124