Mykolo Romerio universiteto mokslo valdymo sistema (CRIS)





Padalinio nuoroda: https://cris.mruni.eu/cris/handle/007/20057
Rodoma1 - 10 iš 15
  • Item type:ETD,
    The Role of Dissenting Opinion in the Final Acts of the Constitutional Court
    [Nesutinkančios nuomonės vaidmuo Konstitucinio Teismo baigiamuosiuose aktuose]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Havryshko, Iryna

    This research examines the role of dissenting opinions in the final acts of constitutional courts, focusing on their legal nature, functions and impact on judicial decision-making. The study combines doctrinal and comparative analysis of the practices of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany and the Supreme Court of the United States, as well as relevant international standards. Particular attention is paid to the discrepancy between the normative regulation of dissenting opinions in Ukraine and their actual application in judicial practice. The results of the research demonstrate that dissenting opinions serve as an important instrument for enhancing transparency, accountability and the quality of judicial reasoning, while also raising concerns regarding legal certainty and institutional authority. Based on the findings, the study systematizes the theoretical and practical aspects of dissenting opinions, evaluates their impact on the legitimacy and authority of constitutional courts, identifies gaps in Ukrainian legislation, and proposes targeted legislative improvements.

      4  1
  • Item type:ETD,
    Freedom of Expression in the Digital Age
    [Saviraiškos laisvė skaitmeniniame amžiuje]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Malakhivska, Lidiya

    This master thesis critically explores the evolution of freedom of expression in the digital age, examining how European legal frameworks – specifically the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and European Union (EU) law – balance this fundamental right against the unique challenges of algorithmic curation, privatized internet governance, and competing human rights. The primary objectives of the research are to identify the historical and legal foundations of free speech, assess the disruptive impact of the digital architecture (namely its speed, scale, and permanence), evaluate the EU's shift toward "European digital constitutionalism" via the Digital Services Act (DSA) and General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), and analyze judicial balancing tests applied by the ECtHR and CJEU. The research concludes that the traditional conception of freedom of expression as a purely negative liberty is structurally inadequate for the modern "algorithmic marketplace of ideas." The unchecked power of private intermediaries necessitates robust procedural safeguards and algorithmic transparency to prevent severe online harms without triggering "collateral censorship." Furthermore, resolving the tension between uninhibited expression, hate speech, and the "right to be forgotten" relies on dynamic judicial proportionality tests that rigorously prioritize informational self- determination and public order without sacrificing democratic pluralism.

      13  2
  • Item type:ETD,
    Constitutional Complaint - The Effectiveness of Individual Constitutional Complaints: a Comparative Analysis
    [Konstitucinis skundas - individualių konstitucinių skundų veiksmingumas: lyginamoji analizė]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Osadcha, Nadiia

    The master's thesis examines the legal nature of the individual constitutional complaint, its role as a mechanism of constitutional control, as well as the effectiveness of its adjudication. The work covers both theoretical and practical aspects: starting from the historical aspects of individual constitutional complaint among multiple jurisdictions to the assessment of actual necessity of this instrument and its influence in modern time, based on examples of Ukraine, the Republic of Lithuania and the Federal Republic of Germany. Main attention is paid to applicability of this mechanism in modern legal systems of constitutional control, in conjunction with multinational and supranational institutions. The work contains the author's recommendations for improving the legislative regulation and mechanisms for the protection of constitutional rights using the mechanism of constitutional control.

      4  14
  • Item type:ETD,
    Climate Change and Human Rights
    [Klimato kaita ir žmogaus teisės]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Khelaiia, Sofiia

    The master thesis examines the link between climate change and the realization of fundamental human rights. Through a range of legal acts, it analyses the gradual recognition of this link and its significance. The study addresses the adverse impacts of climate change on the enjoyment of several fundamental human rights, including the right to life, health and an adequate standard of living, as well as its impact on the rights of vulnerable groups. It also examines the emergence and development of environmental human rights, particularly the right to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment, together with the corresponding State obligations in the field of environmental protection. The thesis evaluates the effectiveness of human rights protection mechanisms, both judicial and alternative, and their adequacy in the context of climate change. It analyses relevant case law concerning climate-related human rights violations and approaches to assessing the admissibility of relevant applications. The research identifies challenges in ensuring adequate protection of human rights against the adverse effects of climate change and highlights the need for further development of existing legal policies and protection mechanisms.

      3  16
  • Item type:ETD,
    The Role of Ombudsperson Institution in Eastern and Central European Countries
    [Ombudsmeno institucijos vaidmuo Rytų ir Vidurio Europos šalyse]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Chernobrova, Kateryna

    This thesis examines the effectiveness of the ombudsperson institution as a mechanism of human rights protection in Europe. Through a comparative-legal analysis of Nordic, Iberian, and Central and Eastern European models - assessed against the Venice Commission's Principles on the Protection and Promotion of the Ombudsman Institution (2019) and UN General Assembly Resolution A/RES/79/177 (2024) - and through case studies. The research demonstrates that the non-binding character of ombudsperson recommendations constitutes a functional advantage in conditions of rule-of-law erosion, that constitutional-review standing is the single most consequential institutional design variable for effective rights protection, and that the contemporary expansion of the ombudsperson's mandate marks a qualitative transformation of the institution from a complaint-handling body into a multi-functional National Human Rights Institution. The findings are directly relevant to Ukraine's ongoing institutional reform process in the context of post-war reconstruction and European Union accession.

      6  13
  • Item type:ETD,
    The Role of Quasi-Court Institutions in European Countries
    [Kvaziteisminių institucijų vaidmuo Europos šalyse]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Chyzhykovska, Sofiia

    The master thesis examines functioning of quasi-court institutions in several European countries. In the first Chapter the definition of a quasi-court institution was analyzed. Besides, some significant features and classification of the institution were distinguished. Case law provided with deeper understanding and explanation of the features of quasi-courts. In the second Chapter quasi-courts on the European Union level were considered. In particular, functioning of different Boards of European Union Agencies were deeply analyzed and compared with significant features of a quasi-court institution. Additionally, this Chapter describes European Ombudsman as a type of quasi-court institution, its powers and procedure of case resolution. In the third Chapter system of quasi-courts in Lithuania, France, Germany and the United Kingdom were examined. The analysis provides also with the examination of importance of each institution. Moreover, the comparison of the systems of these countries were given in the master thesis.

      4  17
  • Item type:ETD,
    Fundamental Rights Impact Assessment as Human Rights Protection Tool under EU AI Act
    [Pagrindinių teisių poveikio vertinimas kaip žmogaus teisių apsaugos priemonė pagal ES AI įstatymą]
    magister thesis[2026][S001]
    Buchynskyi, Maksym

    This thesis asks whether the Fundamental Rights Impact Assessment (FRIA) under Article 27 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 actually protects fundamental rights before high-risk AI is deployed, or whether it ends up as a paper exercise - and what design lessons follow for Ukraine. The study sets out the constitutional foundation of the AI Act under Article 114 TFEU and the New Legislative Framework, traces the relationship between high-risk AI deployment and the Charter of Fundamental Rights, and draws normative criteria from the Data Protection Impact Assessment under Article 35 GDPR and from the Human Rights Impact Assessment tradition. It then analyses Article 27 doctrinally and compares it against the HRIA and DPIA, the Dutch FRAIA, the Canadian Directive on Automated Decision-Making, and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive. The central finding is that Article 27 is built in a way that pushes deployers toward box-ticking: it satisfies none of the four HRIA process criteria as binding legal requirements and only partly meets the content criteria. The thesis turns that diagnosis into a connected set of seven design choices for Ukraine, grounded in Articles 3 and 22 of the Constitution and tailored to Draft Law No. 8153, the National AI Concept, and wartime institutional capacity. It shows that approximation under Article 474 of the EU- Ukraine Association Agreement requires Ukraine to reach the same protective result as EU law, which permits (and in fact calls for) a Ukrainian FRIA stronger than its EU model.

      5  16
  • Item type:ETD,
    The Institute of Constitutional Liability (Impeachment) in The System of Checks and Balances: Comparative Analysis
    [Konstitucinės atsakomybės (apkaltos) institutas kontrolės ir atskaitomybės sistemoje: lyginamoji analizė]
    magister thesis[2025][S001]
    Seleznov, Mark

    The master's thesis is devoted to a comprehensive study of the institute of constitutional and legal responsibility in the form of impeachment in the system of checks and balances. The work analyzes the theoretical foundations of impeachment, its historical evolution and modern legal regulation in different countries. Special attention is paid to a comparative analysis of impeachment in the USA, South Korea, Brazil, Ukraine and Lithuania, which allows assessing the effectiveness of this mechanism in different political and legal systems. The role of impeachment as a means of ensuring the responsibility of senior officials before society is studied, its legal and political aspects are analyzed, as well as the threats associated with its politicization. Attention is paid to the influence of disinformation campaigns on the impeachment procedure and the role of social networks in shaping public opinion regarding this process. The problems of determining the grounds for impeachment and their practical implementation both in Ukraine and in other states are analyzed. The paper makes recommendations for improving Ukrainian legislation and the practice of applying impeachment, aimed at increasing its effectiveness and preventing its use as a tool of political pressure.

      44  1
  • Item type:ETD,
    Topical Issues of Limiting Right to Freedom of Expression in the Internet Space
    [Aktualūs teisės į saviraiškos laisvę ribojimo interneto erdvėje klausimai]
    magister thesis[2025][S001]
    Antypenko, Oleksandra

    This master's thesis addresses the topical issues of limiting the right to freedom of expression in the Internet space. It explores the concept and essence of the right to freedom of expression, its legal regulation, and the specific aspects of its application in the digital environment. The thesis examines current international legal frameworks, the practices of the European Court of Human Rights, and the UN Human Rights Committee in protecting this right. It also analyzes the specifics of judicial practice related to the protection of the right to freedom of expression in the Internet space in Ukraine. The research highlights the challenges in ensuring the proportionality of restrictions on freedom of expression in the digital space and proposes strategies for improving legislation governing this right in Ukraine, especially considering its status as a candidate state to the European Union. This work emphasizes the importance of balancing individual freedoms with the need for responsible digital governance and provides recommendations for developing effective, proportionate, and rights-respecting legal frameworks.

      35  23
  • Item type:ETD,
    Implementation of Fundamental Human Rights and Freedoms under Martial Law in Ukraine
    [Pagrindinių žmogaus teisių ir laisvių įgyvendinimas karo padėties sąlygomis Ukrainoje]
    magister thesis[2025][S001]
    Kuryshchuk, Dmytro

    The master's thesis examines the legal nature of the martial law regime, the impact of the armed aggression of the Russian Federation on the implementation and protection of fundamental human rights and freedoms in Ukraine, as well as the issue of compliance with the principle of proportionality of restrictions applied in an emergency situation, in particular under martial law. The work covers both theoretical and practical aspects: from the historical experience of martial law in different countries of the world to the assessment of actual measures taken in Ukraine during the martial law. Particular attention is paid to the analysis of Ukraine's derogation from its obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights, as well as to the problems of exercising the right to a fair trial and the possibilities of compensation for damage caused as a result of armed aggression of Russian Federation. The work contains the author's recommendations for improving the legislative regulation and mechanisms for the protection of human rights during the armed conflict.

      24  79