Tvaronavičienė, Agnė
Designing an Effective Mandatory Mediation Model: Guidelines from the International Jurisprudence and National Constitutional LimitsItem type:Publikacija, [Розробка ефективної моделі обов'язкової медіації: керівні принципи міжнародної юриспруденції та національні конституційні обмеження.]research article[2025][S1][S001][28]; ; Access to justice in Eastern Europe., 2025, p. 36-63Background: The general development of mediation in Europe has been inspired by a number of Council of Europe recommendations and strongly supported by the European Union. However, clear rules with respect to mandatory mediation have never been established, leaving it to national legislators to decide whether and in what form mandatory mediation may be introduced. This has sparked public debate over the last two decades in several Member States that have introduced mandatory mediation as a measure to foster mediation. While some Member States, like Italy and Lithuania, have already introduced specific models of mandatory mediation, others, like Romania and Bulgaria, continue to express doubts about the coexistence of mandatory mediation and the effective right to justice. This article aims to compare international and national approaches towards mandatory mediation, seeking to identify guidelines for national legislators planning to introduce mandatory mediation models. Methods: The primary methods used in preparing this article combined systematic analysis of the scientific literature related to various forms and models of mandatory mediation with a doctrinal analysis of supranational legal regulation in the field of mandatory mediation. This was complemented by a thematic review of key judgments from the Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights. The research was further enriched by an examination of the legal frameworks and constitutional case law of a few selected countries: Italy, Romania and Bulgaria. This approach involved mapping the examined sources according to their hierarchy—starting with binding EU-level instruments, followed by recommendatory ones, and moving vertically down to domestic statutes and relevant case law. The source selection criteria established at the outset of the research included whether the respective legal source explicitly referenced mandatory mediation and relied on Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Additionally, a qualitative content analysis was conducted on significant national constitutional case law from Italy, Romania and Bulgaria to identify a possible list of criteria for constitutionally unchallengeable mandatory mediation models that could be adopted by countries seeking new effective ways to foster mediation. Results and conclusions: The research identified common concerns regarding the introduction of mandatory mediation and proposed a set of criteria to ensure a balance between the mandate to mediate and the right to access to justice. It was concluded that, when narrowly tailored and supported by robust safeguards, mandatory or quasi-mandatory mediation can reduce court congestion and encourage earlier settlement without undermining fundamental procedural rights. The overarching European framework already provides adequate human-rights guidance; however, the remaining implementation gap lies in national design choices concerning exemptions, cost allocation, and mediator accreditation. Embedding an automatic yet non-binding first session, guaranteeing legal-aid coverage and interpreter services, aligning mediator-quality rules, and tracking compliance through digital case-management tools would make it less likely that mediation degenerates into a mere box-ticking exercise. Future research should observe the durability of settlements and overall user satisfaction to ensure that efficiency gains do not erode meaningful access to justice.
24 18Scopus© citavimai 2 - book[2025][K5][S005,S001,S003,S007,S008,S006][746]
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; Giedrė Valūnaitė-OleškevičienėVilnius : Mykolo Romerio universitetas, 2025457 91 The Implementation of Consensual Tenet in Modern Civil Procedure: Comparative Analysis of Court-Connected Settlement Procedures Applied in Austria, Lithuania, and UkraineItem type:Publikacija, research article[2024][S1][S001][32] ;Tsuvina, Tetiana ;Ferz, Sascha; Riener, PaulaAccess to justice in Eastern Europe., 2024, p. 1-32Background: In this article, the co-authors continue exploring the observable changes in the orientation of civil procedure, moving from competitive and adversarial models towards more cooperative and consensual approaches. Specifically, this work aims to disclose the peculiarities of practically implementing the principles of mutual cooperation and consensuality in civil procedure. The research delves into court-connected settlement procedures in three European countries: Austria, Lithuania, and Ukraine. Through a comparative analysis of the legal regulations and practices in the selected countries, the article evaluates the impact of the application of settlement-oriented procedures on fostering a more amicable resolution of civil disputes. Methods: Research commenced with a review of the existing scientific literature, a brief historical analysis, and a document analysis concerning the legal framework of settlement-oriented procedures applied in the civil process in selected countries. This work is the continuation of the previous research of the co-authors, aiming to explore how the identified global trend of the drift towards a consensual tenet in the civil procedure was reflected in the selected countries’ legal legislation and practice. The Austrian, Lithuanian, and Ukrainian legal frameworks of court-connected settlement-oriented procedures were compared to acknowledge the existing variety and specifics of national approaches towards consensuality in the civil procedure in different jurisdictions. Results and Conclusions: The ideas of a more socially oriented and consensual civil procedure are implemented in the civil procedure of Austria, Lithuania, and Ukraine through the introduction of settlement-oriented methods of dispute resolution, such as court conciliation and court mediation. Despite the wide common understanding of these amicable procedures, essential differences in the theoretical understanding of the concept and its implementation in the analysed jurisdiction were identified. This research assists dispute resolution practitioners and researchers interested in better understanding the implementation of court-connected settlement-oriented procedures in different jurisdictions.
29 17Scopus© citavimai 1 Mediacijos instituto teisinio reguliavimo tobulinimas: nuo profesinės savivaldos teisės mediatoriams suteikimo iki privalomosios mediacijos modelio pokyčiųItem type:Publikacija, [Improving the Legal Regulation of the Institute of Mediation: from Granting Mediators‘ Professional Self-governance Right to Improving the Model of the Mandatory Mediation.]research article[2024][S4][S001][15]; Lietuvos teisė 2024: esminiai pokyčiai., p. 219-233Atsižvelgdama į 2022 m. atliktame privalomosios mediacijos šeimos ginčuose galiojančio teisinio reguliavimo poveikio ex post vertinime pateiktas ekspertų rekomendacijas, 2024 m. Lietuvos Respublikos teisingumo ministerija inicijavo Mediacijos įstatymo ir susijusių teisės aktų pakeitimus. Jais tobulinamas nuo 2020 m. sausio 1 d. Lietuvoje taikomas privalomosios mediacijos modelis, be kita ko, išplečiant mediatorių, teikiančių valstybės finansuojamos privalomosios mediacijos paslaugas, funkcijas. Lietuvos mediatorių rūmams suteikiamas institucijos, įgyvendinančios mediatorių savivaldą, statusas ir tobulinamas mediacijos proceso teisinis reguliavimas, detalizuojant ir išgryninant tam tikras specifines, iki šiol praktikoje kėlusias neaiškumų nuostatas. Pokyčiais, kurie pristatomi ir vertinami šiame straipsnyje, siekiama mediacijos paslaugų kokybės gerinimo ir mediatoriaus profesijos stiprinimo. Sistemiškai vertinant galimą jų poveikį tolesniam mediacijos instituto vystymuisi Lietuvoje, analizuojami ir iššūkiai, kurie galėtų apsunkinti šių pokyčių tikslo pasiekimą.
54 34 Free movement of mediators across the European Union: a new frontier yet to be accomplished?Item type:Publikacija, research article[2023][S1][S001][24]; Access to justice in Eastern Europe., 2023, p. 83-106.This article explores the challenges that stem from the existing national legislation in the field of mediators’ profession regulations on an EU level. It identifies some professional and training requirements in this area and analyses their impact on the freedom and quality of the mediation services offered from one Member State to the other. It further outlines the variety of regulatory models and accreditation practices that apply towards mediators having been certified in the Union or third countries and puts this in the context of spreading mandatory mediation models. The authors explore the different procedures that apply to training and accreditation to see the similarities and differences in the professional standards that apply and their impact on the mediation settlement agreements reached. Methods: Research commenced with a review of the existing scientific literature, a brief overview of the national regulation on the mediators’ profession, and a document analysis concerning the recognition and accreditation of mediators in the EU. This was followed by a comparative study of training requirements and court-related mediation procedures that exist in a number of jurisdictions like Bulgaria, Lithuania, and Italy to highlight some of the main differences. Results and Conclusions: The analyses of the existing national legislation in the field of mediators’ profession regulations on an EU level showed that it is hard or nearly impossible for mediators trained in one EU Member State to render mediation services in other Member States. The existing regulations, coupled with the diverse national training requirements, call for adopting uniform training standards with a synchronised and applicable curriculum across all states. The authors see this as one of the ways to increase the trust in the quality of the mediation service to be of a certain fixed standard and to support the numerous mandatory mediation schemes which in cross-border disputes raise the question of the suitability of the mediator assisting parties in such a dispute resolution process.
27 15Scopus© citavimai 2 The implementation of consensual tenet in modern civil procedure: A European approach of court-related amicable dispute resolution proceduresItem type:Publikacija, research article[2023][S1][S001][27] ;Tsuvina, Tetiana; Riener, PaulaAccess to justice in Eastern Europe. Kyiv : Publishing House VD Dakor, 2023, vol. 6, iss. 1., p. 198-224Background: This article explores the global changes in the orientation of civil procedure from competitive and adversarial towards more cooperative and consensual models. It aims to identify the reflection of mentioned tendencies in the valid legal regulation and practice of modern civil procedure. The consensual tenet in the civil process is analysed from the perspective of civil procedure goals, settlement principle, and case management as an effective tool for implementing the latter in practice. The authors explore the court-related amicable dispute resolution procedures to see the similarities and differences. Methods: Research commenced with a review of the existing scientific literature, a brief historical analysis, and a document analysis concerning changes in civil procedure orientation towards less competitive and more cooperation-grounded resolution of civil disputes. This research was followed by the comparative study of court-related amicable dispute resolution procedures with examples in particular legal jurisdictions like Austria, Lithuania, and Ukraine. Results and Conclusions: Vital changes in the perception of civil procedure regarding the widely accepted need to foster settlements in civil disputes, and an analysis of the most commonly used procedures as court conciliation and court mediation, were presented in this paper. The authors distinguish and analyse three court-related amicable dispute resolution procedures – conciliation, mediation, and the amicable conciliation process, emphasising their peculiarities and features. This research assists dispute resolution practitioners and researchers interested in better understanding how different court-related amicable dispute resolution procedures can be implemented in legal regulation and practice.
57 24Scopus© citavimai 1 - annotation[2023][S8][S001][2]
; Mokslinės minties šventė 2023 : studentų mokslinių straipsnių rinkinys., p. 9-10.20 11 Mandatory mediation in family disputes – an emerging trend in the European Union?Item type:Publikacija, research article[2023][S1a][S001][33]; ; Review of European and Comparative Law, 2023, vol. 53, no. 2, p. 67-99The Mediation Directive (2008) obliged the Member States of the European Union to promote the use of mediation through their own means. A decade later, the results of several studies revealed that national efforts to foster mediation were not as effective as planned in most cases. Despite some scholars’ concerns about restricting mediation voluntariness as means for increasing its application, Italy introduced a mandatory mediation scheme which proved that forcing parties to mediate results in high numbers of mediation procedures with favorable success rates. This led other Member States to reconsider the role of the State in fostering mediation. This article tackles the prevalence of mandatory mediation in family disputes, as an area widely recognized as most suitable for it. The co-authors raised the research question of whether the introduction of mandatory mediation in family disputes is an emerging trend in the European Union. A short overview of the mandatory mediation concept and the existing doctrinal models was presented as a theoretical background of this research. Based on the review of the scientific literature, four prevailing models were identified and briefly described. Secondly, the map of mandatory mediation within the European Union was updated with the latest data collected from the most recent legislative amendments and testimonies of the corresponding national mediation experts. Thirdly, a brief examination of the current mandatory mediation models in the Member States was conducted. The in-depth analysis of the obtained results shows that introducing mandatory mediation in family disputes is a prevailing trend in fostering mediation in the European Union. Consequently, it was identified that the variety of implemented models went far beyond the existing doctrinal classification, which needs to be reconsidered by future research in this field.
23 32Scopus© citavimai 9 Privalomosios mediacijos šeimos ginčuose teisinio reguliavimo poveikio ex post vertinimas kaip paskata tolimesniems pozityviems pokyčiamsItem type:Publikacija, [The Ex-post Evaluation of Legal Regulation: Assessing the Impact of the Legal Regulation of Mandatory Mediation in Family Disputes as an Incentive for Further Positive Changes.]research article[2023][S4][S001][15]; Lietuvos teisė 2023: esminiai pokyčiai., p. 176-190Teisės aktų vertinimas yra sudėtinė teisėkūros ciklo dalis. Priimdamas teisės aktą įstatymo leidėjas negali numatyti, ar pavyks įgyvendinti užsibrėžtą konkretaus teisinio regulia vimo tikslą, todėl retrospektyvinis ex post teisėkūros tyrimas leidžia įvertinti konkrečios iniciatyvos veiksmingumą ir identifikuoti problemines jos vietas. Siekiant įvertinti 2020 m. sausio 1 dieną Lietuvoje įsigaliojusių nuostatų dėl privalomosios mediacijos sprendžiant šeimos ginčus poveikį teisinei sistemai, 2023 m. visuomenei buvo pristatytas pirmasis Lietuvoje pagal naująją metodiką atliktas teisinio reguliavimo ex post vertinimas, kuris sudarė prielaidas mediacijos instituto tobulinimui pasiūlant naujas teisėkūros iniciatyvas, paremtas svarbiausiomis ex post tyrimo rekomendacijomis. Šiame straipsnyje analizuojama atlikto ex post vertinimo eiga, tyrimo grupei kilę iššūkiai ir atskleidžiamas jo poveikis Lietuvos teisinės sistemos raidai.
43 37 Teisminės mediacijos Lietuvoje raida ir galimos tobulinimo kryptys: teisėjų požiūrio tyrimasItem type:Publikacija, [The development of judicial mediation in Lithuania and possible directions for its improvement: the study of judges’ attitudes]research article[2023][S4][S001][29]; ; Jurisprudencija = Jurisprudence, 2023, vol. 30, no. 1, p. 209-237Teisminė mediacija Lietuvoje taikoma jau daugiau nei penkiolika metų. Per šį laikotarpį šio alternatyvaus ginčų sprendimo būdo taikymo Lietuvoje modelis nuolat keitėsi ir susidūrė su įvairiais iššūkiais. Nuo teisėjų modelio iki rinkos modelio ir atvirkštinė transformacija rodo tai, kad šis institutas vis dar vystosi. Straipsnio tikslas – įvertinti esamą teisminės mediacijos Lietuvoje situaciją ir, remiantis teisėjų požiūriu, nustatyti galimas šiuo metu taikomo modelio tobulinimo kryptis. Siekiant šio tikslo vadovautasi šiuo metu taikomo Lietuvoje teisminės mediacijos modelio teisine struktūra, statistiniais duomenimis apie šio alternatyvaus ginčo sprendimo teismuose būdo taikymo praktiką ir buvo siekiama išsiaiškinti teisėjų, kaip šio proceso dažniausių iniciatorių ir jame mediatorių paslaugas teikiančių subjektų, požiūrį į teisminę mediaciją ir jų turimą viziją dėl šio instituto tolimesnio vystymosi perspektyvų. Straipsnyje glaustai aptariama teisminės mediacijos Lietuvoje istorinė raida, apibrėžiamas esamas teisminės mediacijos civiliniame procese modelis ir jo ypatumai, pateikiami empirinio teisėjų nuomonės ir požiūrio į teisminę mediaciją tyrimo rezultatai, taip pat apibendrinimai. Empirinis tyrimas buvo atliktas derinant tarpusavyje kiekybinį (teisėjų ir teisėjų teismo mediatorių apklausa) ir kokybinį (teisėjų ir teisėjų teismo mediatorių sutelktųjų (focus) grupių diskusijų) tyrimų metodus. Konstatuotina, kad teisminės mediacijos institutas Lietuvoje, siekiant jo tvarumo ir sėkmingos tolimesnės taikymo praktikos, teisėjų požiūriu, galėtų būti tobulinamas daugiau dėmesio skiriant tolimesniam jo viešinimui, teisėjų teismo mediatorių darbo sąlygų gerinimui, teismo mediatorių teisėjų motyvacinės sistemos apsvarstymui. Šio tyrimo rezultatai sukuria prielaidas tolimesniems tyrimams, nukreiptiems į teisminės mediacijos teisinio reguliavimo tobulinimą.
45 17